The Suttons flee to safety, while Mabel continues her pursuit of the truth. Gordon receives an unpleasant visit from a fellow government agent.

Gordon’s role in the Suttons disappearance becomes clear, while his dream of a perfect family begins to fall apart.

Abigail discovers a dark secret about Gordon’s work. Gordon confronts Mabel about her trip to the Sutton Farm, and a neighbor approaches Gordon with a unique question.

Days before their own disappearance, Glennie and Gilberto Sutton reckon with the kidnapping of their daughter. Gordon follows Mabel as she visits a person of interest in the alien abduction case.

Mabel uncovers more information about the alien abduction, while Gordon plans a family-bonding trip with his wife and their new daughter Abigail.

In 1956, Federal Agent Gordon Rogers investigates the reported alien abduction of a Native American family living in rural Connecticut.